Current approach to fighting covid-19 may be flawed and based on weak evidence

▴ Covid-19
Flawed models of prognosis being proposed for medical decision-making, say researchers

The modelling and approach to tackle the hard medical decisions associated with the spread of the covid-19 virus may be based on weak and overly-optimistic evidence from studies that are biased and unreliable, suggests research published by The BMJ today.

European researchers examined multiple studies on the virus and found some were poorly reported, had a high risk of being biased and included recommendations that were questionable should they be put into practice.

The covid-19 pandemic is considered to pose a significant and urgent threat to global health with numbers of cases and deaths rising steadily in many countries.

Since the outbreak began in December of last year, it has put a strain on healthcare systems and focused the need for efficient early detection, diagnosis of patients suspected of the infection, and prognosis for confirmed cases.

The current viral nucleic acid testing and chest computed tomography (CT) are standard methods for diagnosing covid-19, but are time-consuming.

So a team of international experts from Maastricht University, KU Leuven, University Medical Center Utrecht, Oxford University, Medical University of Vienna, Keele University, and Leiden University, in collaboration with the Cochrane Prognosis Methods group, set out to review and appraise prediction models for diagnosis and prognosis of covid-19 infection from published and pre-print reports.

All of these models aimed to predict either the presence of existing covid-19 infection, future complications in individuals already diagnosed, or models to identify individuals at high risk for covid-19 in the general population.

They focused on 27 studies that described 31 prediction models.

The vast majority (25) of studies used data on covid-19 cases from China, one study used data on Italian cases, and one study used international data (among others, United States, United Kingdom and China). Collectively, data were gathered between 8 December 2019 and 15 March 2020.

The researchers’ analysis identified three models to predict hospital admission from pneumonia and other events (as a substitution for covid-19 pneumonia) in the general population, as well as 18 diagnostic models to detect covid-19 infection in symptomatic individuals, 13 of which were machine learning utilising CT results.

In addition, they identified 10 prognostic models for predicting mortality risk, a person’s progression to a severe state, or length of hospital stay.

The researchers found that all the studies they analysed were rated as having a high risk of bias, mostly because:

they had a non-representative selection of control patients

they excluded patients who were still ill at the end of the study

they had poor statistical analysis.

The quality of reporting in the studies varied substantially and a description of the study population and intended use of the models was absent in almost all reports with calibration of predictions rarely being assessed.

Prediction models for covid-19 were being produced quickly to help support medical decision making because of the urgent need, said the researchers, and they acknowledge that clinical data from covid-19 patients is still scarce and all studies were done under severe time constraints.

However, they conclude: “Our review indicates proposed models are poorly reported and at high risk of bias. Thus, their reported performance is likely optimistic and using them to support medical decision making is not advised.”

This raised concern that the “models may be flawed and perform poorly when applied in practice, such that their predictions may be unreliable”.

They recommend immediate sharing of the individual participant data from covid-19 studies in order to support collaborative efforts in building “more rigorously developed prediction models” and evaluating existing models.

“We also stress the need to follow methodological guidance when developing and validating prediction models, as unreliable predictions may cause more harm than benefit when used to guide clinical decisions,” they conclude.

The researchers will continue updating the evidence, in a so-called living review to ensure health care professionals have the most recent information about availability and quality of diagnostic and prognostic models.

Tags : #BMJ #Flawedprognosis #Covid19

About the Author


Team Medicircle

Related Stories

18 Jan

National Startup Awards 2021

The National Startup Awards 2021 was launched with the aim to highlight the efforts and achievements of startups towards making India Self-Reliant & Self-Confident. Read to find out more.

View
04 Jan

Covid Vaccination: Has everyone received COVID vaccination?

Are you vaccinated? Protect yourself from the variants of the corona by taking your vaccine. Many people are falling prey to the corona. Make sure you get vaccinated today!!

View
09 Jan

Corona has enabled people to go back to original Indian ethos and practices: Jitendra Singh

Union Minister Dr. Jitendra Singh has said that Corona has enabled people to go back to the original Indian ethos and practices like hand wash and Namaste have come into vogue with greater vigor.

View
02 Jan

Serving government employees to get disability benefit : Dr Jitendra Singh

Order to provide a huge relief to young Central Armed Police Force (CAPF) personnel

View
23 Nov

Dr. Harsh Vardhan addresses Boston Centre for Excellence in Health and Human Development.

Dr. Harsh Vardhan, Union Minister for Health and Family Welfare digitally addressed the Boston Center of Excellence for Health and Human Development here today through Video Conference.

View
09 Nov

Health Minister reviews COVID and public health measures with Health Ministers and senior State officials of 9 States

Union Minister of Health and Family Welfare, Dr. Harsh Vardhan, on Monday, interacted with the State Health Ministers and Principal Secretaries/ Additional Chief Secretaries of 9 states.

View
30 Sep

Urban slum & non-slum areas have higher prevalence of Corona infection than rural areas, says 2nd Sero Survey report

ICMR's second sero-survey findings released on Tuesday has revealed that one in 15 individuals aged 10 years and above were estimated to be exposed to SARS-CoV2 by August, showing that a considerable population is still susceptible to COVID

View
12 Aug

Israel shares AI technology with AIIMS for fighting Coronavirus pandemic

Israeli Ambassador Ron Malka handed over state-of-the-art equipment and technology solutions to the All Indian Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS)

View
02 Aug

India COVID-19 News Updates ; August 2

National Covid-19 updates nationally

View
18 Jul

Diabetics need strict sugar control during Pandemic: Dr Jitendra Singh

Dr Jitendra Singh while addressing 2020 Webinar of Hello Diabetes Academia asks Diabetics to be extra careful

View

-Advertisements-




Trending Now

The Digital Sleep Thief: How Night-time Screen Addiction is Robbing You of Bed-time RestApril 02, 2025
KKR Launches ‘Knight Bite’ – A Digital Series That Serves Up Food, Fun, and Cricket!April 02, 2025
Crompton rolls out its all new range of Aura, Avancer & Jedi Air Coolers for an effortless summer cooling experienceApril 02, 2025
CARE Hospitals, Hi-Tech City Strengthens Orthopaedics Department with Renowned SurgeonsApril 02, 2025
World Autism Awareness Day: Breaking the Chains of Stigma in IndiaApril 02, 2025
From Scroll to Squint: How Reels Are Reshaping Your VisionApril 02, 2025
Moscow Center for Diagnostics and Telemedicine Receives License for Radiology Residency ProgramApril 02, 2025
CARE Hospitals Launches AI-Powered Non-Invasive Therapy – An innovative modality introduced in Telangana & Andhra PradeshApril 02, 2025
High-Rise Heart Attacks: Are Skyscrapers Turning Survival into a Race Against Time?April 02, 2025
DCDC’s $150 Crore Expansion: Can Innovative Clinics End India's Kidney Crisis?April 02, 2025
Medanta Rolls Out ‘Colon Tunnel on Wheels’ to Drive Awareness on Colorectal Cancer Prevention & Early DetectionApril 01, 2025
Zigly launches 2 pet hospitals, opens 4 new stores; expects ARR to more than double in 1-2 yearsApril 01, 2025
University of Leeds Announces International Masters Regional Scholarships for 2025April 01, 2025
Avantor Recognized with Two Prestigious Awards at Asia-Pacific Biopharma Excellence Awards 2025April 01, 2025
Foundation Stone Laid for Madhav Netralaya Eye Hospital & Research CentreApril 01, 2025
Doomscrolling at Midnight: How Indians Are Sacrificing Sleep for ScreensMarch 31, 2025
Essential Medicines Price Surge: Are Patients Paying the Price?March 31, 2025
Prioritize your health during the holy days of RamzanMarch 31, 2025
Tired of Stomach Cramps? These Simple Foods Can Heal Your GutMarch 31, 2025
Regional growth booming for startups in 2024 - QBO Innovation studyMarch 31, 2025