Delaying second covid vaccine dose may prevent deaths under certain conditions

Delay strategy, at least for people under 65, could reduce deaths by up to 20%, say, researchers

Delaying the second dose of covid-19 vaccines, at least for people aged under 65, could result in up to 20% lower mortality, but only under certain conditions, finds a US study published by The BMJ recently.

These conditions include one-dose vaccine effectiveness (efficacy) of 80% or higher and vaccination rates of 0.1% to 0.3% of the population per day. If these conditions apply, the researchers say the strategy could prevent between 47 and 26 deaths per 100,000 people, respectively.

Both the Pfizer and Moderna covid-19 vaccines in a standard two-dose schedule are highly effective at preventing symptomatic infections and death. But immunity worldwide remains low, partly owing to low vaccination rates.

The longer it takes to effectively vaccinate the global population, the greater the likely risk of vaccine-resistant strains developing. This has led to calls to prioritize single-dose vaccination for as many people as possible, even if this means delaying a second dose beyond the studied time frame.

The justification for this relies on the assumption that meaningful protection against covid-19 can be achieved after a single dose of vaccine, but this is the subject of intense debate.

To explore this further, a team of US researchers set out to measure the impact of delayed second dose vaccine policies on infections, hospital admissions, and deaths compared with the current on-schedule two-dose regimen.

Using a simulation model based on a “real-world” sample population of 100,000 US adults, they ran a series of scenarios to forecast potentially infectious interactions under different conditions over a six-month period.

These included varying levels of vaccine efficacy and administration rates, and varying assumptions as to whether the vaccine prevents transmission and serious symptoms or only prevents serious symptoms, including death.

They also examined the impact of delaying second doses for those younger than 65, but not before fully vaccinating older people.

The results suggest that under specific conditions a decrease in cumulative mortality, infections, and hospital admissions can be achieved when the second vaccine dose is delayed.

The study replicated the simulations several times and used that data to estimate different population-level outcomes. For example, for a first dose efficacy of 80% and a daily vaccine administration rate of 0.1%, 0.3% and 1% of the population, the estimated total mortality per 100,000 for the delayed versus standard second-dose administration were 402 versus 442, 204 versus 241, and 86 versus 50, respectively.

These results suggest that a delayed second dose strategy is optimal for vaccination rates at or lower than 0.3% population per day if the vaccine efficacy from one dose is 80% or greater.

What’s more, the delayed second dose strategy for people under 65 performed consistently well under all vaccination rates tested, resulting in absolute cumulative mortality reductions up to an estimated 48 per 100,000.

These two conditions seem reasonable on the basis of the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) estimate of first dose vaccine efficacy being 80% and only a couple countries such as the US and UK reaching a vaccination rate close to 1%, explain the researchers.

They acknowledge some study limitations based on assumptions used in the model, but they aimed to capture the relevant complex human interaction that is critical in covid-19 transmission, across a timeframe that is useful to decision-makers. As such, they say these results may be broadly informative for the covid-19 vaccine strategy.

“Decision-makers will need to consider their local vaccination rates and weigh the benefits of increasing these rates by delaying a second dose versus the risks associated with the remaining uncertainty in this strategy,” they write. “These decisions should continue to be re-evaluated as new data become available,” they add.

Tags : #EfficacyofCOVIDVaccine #TheBMJ #Pfizer #Moderna #AstraZeneca #CDC #Immunity

Related Stories

Loading Please wait...

-Advertisements-




Trending Now

Given the rise in heart attack cases in womenApril 08, 2025
CARE Hospitals Marks World Health Day 2025 with ‘Walk for a Healthy Beginning’ at CharminarApril 08, 2025
Cancer, Obesity, Mental Health, India’s top health concerns: Ipsos Health Service Report 2024 April 08, 2025
Why Loneliness Might Be the Real Reason You're Always Falling SickApril 08, 2025
Is Your Beverage Choice Secretly Harming Your Mind?April 08, 2025
India’s Hidden Health Pandemic: Vitamin D Deficiency Affects One in FiveApril 08, 2025
Xavier University strengthens ties with India through strategic visitApril 08, 2025
Desire, Distraction, and Distress: The Untold Connection of ADHD and SexApril 08, 2025
Medical breakthrough unlocks rare disease discoveryApril 08, 2025
Elevate your space with the Crompton’s 3-star energy efficient, Avancer Swirl Ceiling Fan – a perfect combination of Aesthetics and Technology!April 07, 2025
CARE Hospitals Launches ‘SANGHAM’ Card on World Health DayApril 07, 2025
Sharda Care Healthcity partners with Prometheus School to strengthen awareness on healthy living among communities this World Health DayApril 07, 2025
Sharda Care Healthcity partners with Prometheus School to strengthen awareness on healthy living among communities this World Health DayApril 07, 2025
When the Fight Comes Back: Tahira’s Relapse and the Reality of Breast Cancer Beyond RecoveryApril 07, 2025
Beyond Hospitals and Hashtags: What World Health Day Should Really Teach UsApril 07, 2025
Dermatologist vs. Dettol: Who Should You Trust With Your Skin?April 07, 2025
The Price of Life: How a Pregnant Woman's Death Exposed the Rotten Reality of India's Healthcare SystemApril 07, 2025
Maternal and Infant Health in Focus as India Observes World Health Day 2025April 07, 2025
CARE Hospitals Promotes Safe Motherhood on World Health DayApril 07, 2025
CARE Hospitals Promotes Safe Motherhood on World Health DayApril 07, 2025