Expert finds limited effectiveness of convalescent plasma for covid-19 patients

▴ Expert finds limited effectiveness of convalescent plasma for covid-19 patients
Convalescent plasma fails to reduce deaths or stop progression to severe disease

Convalescent plasma shows limited effectiveness as a potential treatment for patients with covid-19 to help them fight off the infection, finds a clinical trial from India published by The BMJ recently.

The findings show that convalescent plasma fails to reduce mortality or stop progression to severe covid-19.

With few treatment options available for patients with severe or life-threatening covid-19, trials are underway to find out if convalescent plasma (a transfusion of blood plasma from someone who has recovered from covid-19) could help people who are severely ill.

Some countries, including the US and India, have authorised convalescent plasma for emergency use. Others, including the UK, are collecting donated plasma so the treatment can be widely rolled out if it is shown to be effective.

Some observational studies have suggested benefits in those who receive convalescent plasma, but clinical trials have so far failed to show any reduction in deaths, and evidence on its safety and effectiveness remains uncertain.

So researchers in India set out to investigate whether using convalescent plasma to treat moderately ill covid-19 patients was associated with any benefits.

They enrolled 464 adults (average age 52) with confirmed moderate covid-19 who were admitted to 39 public and private hospitals across India between 22 April and 14 July 2020.

Patients were randomly split into two groups. The intervention group (235 patients) received two transfusions of convalescent plasma, 24 hours apart, alongside best standard of care, while the control group (229 patients) received best standard of care only.

All plasma samples were safety checked and levels of neutralising antibodies were measured. All participants underwent clinical examination and a range of laboratory tests at the start of the trial and again on days 1, 3, 5, 7, and 14, and were contacted by telephone on day 28 to assess their health status.

After 28 days, 44 (19%) participants in the intervention group and 41 (18%) in the control group progressed to severe disease or died from any cause. The randomised study design ensured that the only important difference between the two groups of patients was whether or not they received convalescent plasma.

Restricting the comparison to patients who received plasma with detectable antibody levels did not change the results.

Use of convalescent plasma seemed to improve resolution of shortness of breath and fatigue and led to higher negative conversion (a sign that the virus is being neutralised by antibodies) after 7 days. But this did not translate into a reduction in deaths or progression to severe disease by 28 days.

The researchers acknowledge some limitations, such as differences in the number of patients, laboratory tests, and standards of care across the trial sites that may have affected their results.

But they say the wide social, cultural, and economic mix of study participants from both public and private hospitals reflect real world scenarios, and therefore the findings are likely to apply more generally.

As such, they say, in settings with limited laboratory capacity, “convalescent plasma does not reduce 28 day mortality or progression to severe disease in patients admitted to hospital with moderate covid-19.”

As a potential treatment for patients with moderate covid-19, “convalescent plasma showed limited effectiveness,” they conclude. And they say future research could explore using only plasma with high levels of neutralising antibodies, to see if this might be more effective.

This rigorous trial shows that convalescent plasma is ineffective for covid-19, and its implications “should be carefully considered by both safety monitoring and institutional review boards,” argues Dr Elizabeth Pathak in a linked editorial.

High quality clinical research “must be an integral part of a coordinated international response. With publication of these findings, the bar is raised for all ongoing and future trials,” she writes.

Tags : #COVID-19 #TheBMJ #LatestPharmaNews24thOct #LatestNewsonPlasmaTreatment24thOct #DrElizabethPathak #MortalityRate

About the Author


Team Medicircle

Related Stories

03 Apr

Is This the Future of Physiotherapy? Inside Stance Health’s $1M Expansion

With the right mix of expertise, funding, and innovation, the company will not just be filling a gap but also build a future where effective MSK care is accessible to all.

View
03 Apr

The Daily Shower Debate: Are You Washing Away Your Skin’s Health?

Adopting a mindful approach, such as choosing gentle skincare products, limiting shower time, and maintaining hydration, can ensure that your hygiene routine works in harmony with your body’s natural needs.

View
02 Apr

DCDC’s $150 Crore Expansion: Can Innovative Clinics End India's Kidney Crisis?

As the healthcare landscape evolves, initiatives like these will determine the future of medical care in the country.

View
02 Apr

World Autism Awareness Day: Breaking the Chains of Stigma in India

Are we ready to create a world that embraces neurodiversity, or will we continue to let ignorance dictate the lives of millions?

View
02 Apr

The Digital Sleep Thief: How Night-time Screen Addiction is Robbing You of Bed-time Rest

By implementing screen-free bedtime routines, reducing blue light exposure, and prioritizing sleep hygiene, we can reclaim the restful nights we deserve.

View
02 Apr

From Scroll to Squint: How Reels Are Reshaping Your Vision

By adopting healthier screen habits and prioritizing eye care, we can prevent the irreversible damage caused by prolonged digital exposure.

View
02 Apr

High-Rise Heart Attacks: Are Skyscrapers Turning Survival into a Race Against Time?

It’s time to prioritize human life over convenience and invest in smarter urban designs to empower communities with the knowledge and tools needed to act swiftly in times of crisis.

View
31 Mar

Doomscrolling at Midnight: How Indians Are Sacrificing Sleep for Screens

Public health initiatives should address sleep disorders with the same urgency as other health concerns. By prioritizing sleep, India can take a major step towards improving overall well-being and productivity.

View
31 Mar

Tired of Stomach Cramps? These Simple Foods Can Heal Your Gut

By making mindful food choices, one can significantly reduce symptoms, avoid severe complications, and improve quality of life.

View
31 Mar

Essential Medicines Price Surge: Are Patients Paying the Price?

As the pharmaceutical landscape evolves, the focus must remain on ensuring that life-saving medicines are within everyone’s reach.

View

-Advertisements-




Trending Now

University of Manchester invites applications for MA Social AnthropologyApril 03, 2025
Ahead of World Health Day, Sova Health Launches Advanced Microbiome Tests & Evidence-Based Precision Supplements April 03, 2025
Half of women cannot make decisions about their reproductive health and bodily autonomyApril 03, 2025
UGRO CAPITAL LIMITED PUBLIC ISSUE OF SECURED, RATED, LISTED, REDEEMABLE, NON-CONVERTIBLE DEBENTURES (SECURED NCDS) OPENS TODAY EFFECTIVE ANNUALIZED YIELD UP TO 11.01% PER ANNUM* April 03, 2025
SF Airlines Entrusts Çelebi India with Freighter Handling at Kempegowda International Airport, BengaluruApril 03, 2025
Is This the Future of Physiotherapy? Inside Stance Health’s $1M ExpansionApril 03, 2025
The Daily Shower Debate: Are You Washing Away Your Skin’s Health?April 03, 2025
The Digital Sleep Thief: How Night-time Screen Addiction is Robbing You of Bed-time RestApril 02, 2025
KKR Launches ‘Knight Bite’ – A Digital Series That Serves Up Food, Fun, and Cricket!April 02, 2025
Crompton rolls out its all new range of Aura, Avancer & Jedi Air Coolers for an effortless summer cooling experienceApril 02, 2025
CARE Hospitals, Hi-Tech City Strengthens Orthopaedics Department with Renowned SurgeonsApril 02, 2025
World Autism Awareness Day: Breaking the Chains of Stigma in IndiaApril 02, 2025
From Scroll to Squint: How Reels Are Reshaping Your VisionApril 02, 2025
Moscow Center for Diagnostics and Telemedicine Receives License for Radiology Residency ProgramApril 02, 2025
CARE Hospitals Launches AI-Powered Non-Invasive Therapy – An innovative modality introduced in Telangana & Andhra PradeshApril 02, 2025
High-Rise Heart Attacks: Are Skyscrapers Turning Survival into a Race Against Time?April 02, 2025
DCDC’s $150 Crore Expansion: Can Innovative Clinics End India's Kidney Crisis?April 02, 2025
Medanta Rolls Out ‘Colon Tunnel on Wheels’ to Drive Awareness on Colorectal Cancer Prevention & Early DetectionApril 01, 2025
Zigly launches 2 pet hospitals, opens 4 new stores; expects ARR to more than double in 1-2 yearsApril 01, 2025
University of Leeds Announces International Masters Regional Scholarships for 2025April 01, 2025