Rigid social distancing rules for covid-19 based on outdated science

▴ physical-distancing-wider-public-health-approach-containing-covid19-pandemic
The smaller airborne droplets laden with covid-19 can travel more than 2 metres by activities such as coughing and shouting

Rules which stipulate a single specific physical distance (1 or 2 metres) between individuals to reduce the spread of covid-19 are based on outdated science and experiences of past viruses, argue researchers in The BMJ recently.

Such rules are based on an over-simplistic dichotomy describing viral transfer by either large droplets or small airborne droplets emitted in isolation without accounting for the exhaled air, say Nicholas Jones at the University of Oxford and colleagues.

In reality, transmission is more complex, involving a continuum of droplet sizes and an important role of the exhaled air that carries them, they explain.

Evidence suggests that smaller airborne droplets laden with covid-19 can travel more than 2 metres by activities such as coughing and shouting, and may spread up to 7-8 metres concentrated in exhaled air from an infected person.

As such, they say distancing rules need to take account of the multiple factors that affect risk, including type of activity, indoor versus outdoor settings, level of ventilation and whether face coverings are worn.

Viral load of the emitter, duration of exposure, and susceptibility of an individual to infection are also important, they add.

“This would provide greater protection in the highest risk settings but also greater freedom in lower risk settings, potentially enabling a return towards normality in some aspects of social and economic life,” they write.

To facilitate this, they discuss how transmission risk may vary with setting, occupancy level, contact time, and whether face coverings are worn.

For example, in the highest risk situations, such as a crowded bar or nightclub, physical distancing beyond 2 metres and minimising occupancy time should be considered, while less stringent distancing is likely to be adequate in low risk scenarios.

They say further work is needed to examine areas of uncertainty and extend the guide to develop specific solutions to classes of indoor environments occupied at various usage levels.

Physical distancing should be seen as only one part of a wider public health approach to containing the covid-19 pandemic,” they conclude.

“It should be used in combination with other strategies to reduce transmission risk, including hand washing, regular surface cleaning, protective equipment and face coverings where appropriate, strategies of air hygiene, and isolation of affected individuals.”

Tags : #PhysicalDistancing #COVID-19 #Pandemic #NicholasJones #ViralTransfer #UniversityofOxford

About the Author


Team Medicircle

Related Stories

Loading Please wait...

-Advertisements-




Trending Now

Why are key populations on the blindspot in the global HIV response?July 20, 2024
Exploring the Link Between Tinnitus and Body Composition: What Recent Research RevealsJuly 20, 2024
Surge in Brain Infections in India During Monsoon: A Growing ConcernJuly 20, 2024
We have more infection-prevention options now but are they actual choices for the people?July 19, 2024
New humidity-driven membrane to remove carbon dioxide from the airJuly 19, 2024
Introducing the World's First Consent-Based Data-Sharing Framework Built on Open Standards: The Affinidi Iota Framework July 19, 2024
The Power of Green Spaces: Evidence That Parks May Delay Cognitive DeclineJuly 19, 2024
Strengthening Healthcare in India: The Push for Better Coverage with Ayushman BharatJuly 19, 2024
SARV Events & Celebrations Shines at "Edu-Bizz Leadership Summit & Awards 24July 18, 2024
UAE launches global initiative to build 10 hospitals to address critical healthcare gaps as part of Zayed Humanitarian Legacy InitiativeJuly 18, 2024
Geetanjali Homestate Expands Global Presence with the Launch of Geetanjali GlobalJuly 18, 2024
Changes projected in marine fish communities due to climate changeJuly 18, 2024
Understanding the Chandipura Virus Outbreak in Gujarat: A Critical OverviewJuly 18, 2024
Landmark Study Links Severe Endometriosis to Increased Risk of Ovarian CancerJuly 18, 2024
Equipping Healthcare Professionals for Global Opportunities: GIMS Partners with NSDCJuly 18, 2024
Hormone Modulating Therapy for Breast Cancer and Its Link to Lower Alzheimer’s RiskJuly 18, 2024
Multipl Secures $1.5 Million in Additional Funds, Led by Blume Ventures and MIXI Global Investments, JapanJuly 17, 2024
FedEx to empower youth with digital skilling programJuly 17, 2024
Putting people first means following Gandhi's TalismanJuly 17, 2024
American Oncology Institute (AOI) Launches #BreaktheHabit Campaign to Raise Awareness on Head & Neck cancerJuly 17, 2024