Experts outline key challenges for assessing clinical efficacy of COVID-19 vaccines: The Lancet

▴ Experts outline key challenges for assessing clinical efficacy of COVID-19 vaccines: The Lancet
Determining whether a vaccine can protect against severe disease and death from COVID-19 might not be possible in clinical trials, and will likely require long-term, ongoing studies after any candidate is licenced and deployed

Collaboration and standardised approaches for assessing different vaccine efficacy endpoints are key for meaningful comparison of different COVID-19 vaccine candidates to ensure that the most effective vaccines are deployed, say authors of an opinion piece based on a review of evidence, and published in The Lancet Infectious Diseases journal.

A candidate vaccine against SARS-CoV-2 might act against infection, disease, or transmission, and a vaccine capable of reducing any of these elements could contribute to control of the COVID-19 pandemic. In their Review, the authors highlight key challenges for assessing the efficacy of potential COVID-19 vaccines, to provide insight into the seemingly simple question, “Does this COVID-19 vaccine work?”.

Author of the Review, Dr Susanne Hodgson, University of Oxford, UK, said: “It is unlikely that we will see a single vaccine winner in the race against COVID-19. Different technologies will bring distinct advantages that are relevant in different situations, and additionally, there will probably be challenges with manufacturing and supplying a single vaccine at the scale required, at least initially. Taking a standardised approach to measuring the success of vaccines in clinical trials will be important for making meaningful comparisons, so that the most effective candidates can be taken forward for wider use.” 

Currently, there are 44 candidates in clinical assessment, with a further 154 in preclinical development, reflecting a range of vaccine technologies. The authors argue that to help compare efficacy between these and future candidates, it is important that standardised, quantifiable endpoints are applied to clinical trials of COVID-19 vaccines, and that their limitations and potential for bias are understood.

The authors also highlight a further challenge: evaluating the efficacy of candidate vaccines to protect against severe disease and death from SARS-COV-2 infection. They argue that long-term follow-up of recipients of candidate COVID-19 vaccines will be important, both to evaluate efficacy against severe disease and mortality, and to ensure the ongoing evaluation of vaccine safety.

Co-author, Dr Kate Emary, University of Oxford, UK says: “To determine whether a vaccine protects against severe COVID-19 disease, a clinical trial needs to show that there are significantly fewer cases of severe disease in individuals vaccinated with a COVID-19 vaccine, compared with individuals who were not. However, only a small proportion of individuals infected with SARS-CoV-2 develop severe disease, which means an extremely large number of volunteers is needed in a clinical trial for there to be enough cases to get a reliable measure of vaccine efficacy. This means that it is likely that we will only know if a vaccine protects against severe disease once it has been deployed and given to a large population.” 

The authors also discuss controlled infection studies in humans (challenge trials) as they may offer a way to measure vaccine efficacy as SARS-CoV-2 transmission declines in the community. They argue that while these studies may provide the only means of rapidly assessing a vaccine’s efficacy, the relationship between efficacy in younger individuals in challenge trials and in older and at-risk populations after vaccine deployment remains unclear.

They conclude that in keeping with the development of any novel medical intervention, but particularly so in this context, it is imperative that efficacy outcomes for a SARS-CoV-2 vaccine are critically appraised with scientific rigour to understand their generalisability and clinical significance. They note that although some countries might deploy COVID-19 vaccines on the strength of safety and immunogenicity data alone, the goal of vaccine development is to gain direct evidence of vaccine efficacy in protecting humans against SARS-CoV-2 infection and disease so that manufacture of efficacious vaccines can be selectively upscaled.

Tags : #COVID-19Vaccine #TheLancet #UniversityofOxford #LatestNewsonCOVID-19Vaccine28thOct #DrSusanneHodgson #DrKateEmary #UnitedKingdom

About the Author


Team Medicircle

Related Stories

Loading Please wait...

-Advertisements-




Trending Now

Kaya Expands in Ludhiana with its 76th Clinic, Elevating Skincare with Advanced Wellness Solutions October 09, 2024
Dr Raj Nagarkar Becomes India’s 1st Oncologist on Cambridge Medical Robotics’ Advisory BoardOctober 09, 2024
Workplace Stress and Burnout Rate Reaching Critical Levels for Indian Employees, Warn ExpertsOctober 09, 2024
Are We Really Living Longer? The Surprising Reality of Life Expectancy TodayOctober 09, 2024
Could Your Irregular Heartbeat Be Reversible? How New Research is Redefining Atrial Fibrillation CareOctober 09, 2024
Defying the Odds: The Innovative Treatment Prolonging Life in Advanced Breast CancerOctober 09, 2024
Medanta Doctors Recognised in Stanford University's Global Rankings of Top 2% ScientistsOctober 09, 2024
Vector-Borne Diseases in India: 2024 OverviewOctober 09, 2024
What Makes The Mind Hear Voices: The Truth Behind Hearing Voices in SchizophreniaOctober 08, 2024
Preventing Pregnancy Complications: Why a Healthy Weight Before Conception MattersOctober 08, 2024
Are Your Favorite Beverages Putting You at Risk of Stroke? Here’s What the Latest Research SaysOctober 08, 2024
Sharp Sight Eye Hospitals Emphasizes Importance of Regular Eye Checkups with New Campaign Featuring Shishir SharmaOctober 08, 2024
Microplastics in Bloodstream: The Hidden Link to Cardiovascular and Neurological DisordersOctober 08, 2024
India Joins International Medical Device Regulators Forum: A Leap Toward Global Health CollaborationOctober 05, 2024
The Science of Overeating: Why You Can’t Stop at Just One BiteOctober 05, 2024
The Toxic Truth: How Alcohol Fuels Six Deadly CancersOctober 05, 2024
Lenacapavir: India’s Pharmaceutical Giants to Produce a Twice-a-Year Pill Poised to Rewrite HIV PreventionOctober 04, 2024
Can Ending Smoking by 2050 Really Save 1.2 Million Lives? New Lancet Study RevealsOctober 04, 2024
Colon Cancer Crisis: Why It’s Attacking Younger GenerationsOctober 04, 2024
Eye Health Program for Low-Income Residents Launched in Hingoli, MaharashtraOctober 04, 2024