Second Opinion Gives Eight-Year-Old Boy A Chance To Keep His Leg & His Childhood

▴ Dr Raj Nagarkar - Chief of Surgical Oncology and Robotic Services
Successful Limb-Sparing Surgery For Osteogenic Sarcoma At Nashik’s HCG Manavata Offers Alternative To Amputation.

Nashik, Aug 27: For eight-year-old Sumit from Surat, playing with friends and enjoying a carefree childhood suddenly came to a standstill when he began experiencing pain and difficulty while walking. The routine complaint soon led to a devastating diagnosis - osteogenic sarcoma, a rare and aggressive bone cancer. Investigations revealed a tumour in the bone around the knee, which had also extended beyond the bone into the surrounding soft tissues. The diagnosis meant that the young boy faced not only a prolonged cancer treatment journey but also the possibility of losing his leg. After undergoing four cycles of chemotherapy at a renowned hospital in Mumbai, the family was advised to consider amputation of the affected leg from above the knee. For his parents, the prospect of seeing their child lose his leg was heart-breaking.

 

Determined to explore every possible option, they sought a second opinion at HCG Manavata Cancer Centre (HCGMCC) – Nashik, a decision that would change their lives. Here, Dr Raj Nagarkar - Chief of Surgical Oncology and Robotic Services carefully reviewed Sumit’s medical reports, comparing his older PET-CT and MRI scans with new ones. Remarkably, after four cycles of chemotherapy, the tumour had shrunk significantly and its Standardized Uptake Value (SUV), a measure of cancer activity had dropped to zero, indicating a complete metabolic response to chemotherapy.

 

“When the family came to us, the child was smiling, a beautiful smile that masked the storm within. After reviewing his scans, we found that the cancer appeared to be metabolically inactive. I told the parents that we will try our best to save your child’s leg. That glimmer of hope was all they needed,” says Prof Dr Raj Nagarkar, Chief of Surgical Oncology & Robotic Services and Managing Director, KIMS Manavata Hospitals, HCG Manavata Cancer Centre and Six Sigma, Nashik.

 

The Multidisciplinary team discussed the case and concluded that surgery was essential. However, instead of proceeding directly to amputation, the doctors decided to attempt a limb-sparing procedure, with the final decision to preserve the leg dependent on intraoperative assessment of whether any viable cancer cells remained.

 

“For Sumit’s parents, the possibility of amputation was extremely difficult to accept and we wanted to explore whether there was a medically sound way to preserve his leg. His scans showed an excellent response to chemotherapy, but we could not make the final decision based on imaging alone. We therefore planned the surgery in such a way that we could assess the tumour and the surrounding bone during the procedure and decide whether limb preservation was safe,” adds Dr Nagarkar.

 

During surgery, the affected portion of the bone was removed and immediately sent to the pathology team for rapid intraoperative assessment. Within approximately 15 to 20 minutes, the team confirmed that no viable cancer cells remained in the sampled tissue. With this critical confirmation, the doctors proceeded with limb preservation rather than amputation. The affected bone was further prepared and subjected to high dose radiation in the radiation department to eliminate any microscopic residual cancer cells. The treated bone was then returned to the operating theatre and reconstructed and fixed back into the child’s leg. The complex procedure lasted approximately four hours.

 

“Sumit’s recovery was remarkably swift. He was shifted to his room the following day and began walking with the support of a walker by the third day. He was discharged shortly thereafter and continues to undergo the remaining stages of his cancer treatment. The final pathology report gave us further reassurance indicating the tumour had shown a complete response to the first five cycles of chemotherapy, confirming that the decision to attempt limb preservation had been appropriate. At HCG Manavata Cancer Centre, our focus is not only on treating cancer but also on preserving and improving each patient’s quality of life,” adds Dr Nagarkar.

 

For Sumit and his family, the outcome has meant much more than avoiding an amputation. It has given the young boy the opportunity to look ahead to a future where he can once again run, play and grow up with greater independence. He is currently undergoing continued treatment and physiotherapy and with appropriate rehabilitation, the child may gradually regain the ability to walk over the coming year.

 

“In paediatric cancer, every decision has consequences that extend far beyond the treatment itself. For an eight-year-old, preserving a limb can mean preserving independence, mobility and the ability to return to school, play and everyday life. This was a carefully planned decision based on the child’s response to chemotherapy, intraoperative pathology and the expertise of a multidisciplinary team. While not every child with bone cancer will be a candidate for limb-sparing surgery, cases like Sumit’s demonstrate why a detailed evaluation and an expert second opinion can sometimes open up possibilities that families may not have considered,” concludes Dr Nagarkar.

Tags : #

About the Author


Team Medicircle

Related Stories

Loading Please wait...

-Advertisements-



Trending Now

How Language Access Can Improve Patient Communication in Indian HealthcareOctober 07, 2026
Why Health Literacy Matters in Preventive HealthcareOctober 07, 2026
Improving Follow-Up After Diagnostic Testing: Where Systems Commonly Break DownOctober 07, 2026
Improving Follow-Up After Diagnostic Testing: Where Systems Commonly Break DownOctober 07, 2026
How Community Health Workers Support Preventive Care DeliveryOctober 07, 2026
AI in India's Emergency Departments: Reducing Diagnostic DelaysOctober 06, 2026
AI and Patient Consent in India: Who Is Responsible?October 06, 2026
Wearable Technology in Pregnancy: Benefits and LimitsOctober 06, 2026
Remote Monitoring for High-Risk Pregnancies in IndiaOctober 06, 2026
Fortis Escorts Faridabad Launches ‘Sehat Express’ Mobile Bus for Accessible Doorstep Cancer Screening in association with Faridabad Industries Association Charitable Society and Rotary Club FaridabadOctober 05, 2026
Advanced Thrombectomy Saves 60-Year-Old Woman After Severe Heart Attack at KIMS SaveeraOctober 05, 2026
Constipation, Bloating and Long Sitting Hours: Doctors at RG Hospitals Delhi Warn Urban Professionals Not to Ignore Gut ProblemsOctober 05, 2026
Fermenta – Centre of Excellence for Food Fortification Inaugurated at NIFTEM-T, ThanjavurOctober 05, 2026
Alzheimer’s Dementia: Recognising the Signs, Diagnosing Earlier and Changing the Future of Brain HealthOctober 05, 2026
Man Matters Hairfall Case Study 2026: 7 Lakh+ Consultations Reveal How Hair Loss Changes With AgeOctober 05, 2026
Medication Reconciliation: A System-Level Step for Safer Transitions of CareOctober 05, 2026
The Role of Clinical Pharmacists in Safer Medication UseOctober 05, 2026
Nanavati Max Hospital Hosts Max Cancer Congress 2026, Bringing Together Oncology Experts to Explore the Future of Cancer Care October 01, 2026
Dhiya Fertility and Maternity Center Performs Tamil Nadu’s First Robot-Assisted Fertility Procedure; 37-Year-Old Woman Delivers Healthy Baby GirlOctober 01, 2026
Habuild’s “Are You Still Awake?” Campaign Encourages India to Switch Off, Sleep on Time and Not Take Everything to Heart October 01, 2026